Web designer refusing to create sites for same-sex weddings urges Supreme Court to uphold free speech rights

Lorie Smith, a Colorado graphic designer at the center of a Supreme Court case examining her refusal to create wedding websites for same-sex couples, said the ruling will determine whether she and other service providers can exercise their First Amendment rights in the workplace.

The Supreme Court heard oral arguments Monday in the high-profile case involving Smith, the religious Christian owner of 303 Creative, who is challenging her state’s anti-discrimination laws over her refusal to create websites for same-sex weddings, citing her religious beliefs.

In an interview on "The Story" Monday, Smith said that she wants to use her creative expression to design websites for couples in a way that is consistent with her faith, but feels the state of Colorado is "compelling" her to communicate a message through her designs that promote same-sex marriage and violates "the core" of her religious beliefs.

SUPREME COURT TO TAKE UP CASE OVER FREE SPEECH VS. LGBTQ RIGHTS

"I want to create unique one-of-a-kind expression and artwork and I want to design websites – wedding websites – specifically that are consistent with my faith," Smith told Fox News. "But the state of Colorado is compelling and controlling my speech, chilling it and forcing me to communicate a message through my custom unique artwork. That violates the core of who I am and at the core of this case is the right for all to speak freely and that protects not only myself, protects the LGBT web designer that should not be forced to create custom artwork that opposes same-sex marriage. The right to speak freely is guaranteed to each and every one of us and a win for me is a win for everybody."

The case is structured around a private company's refusal to create any website for a same-sex wedding, despite the state's Colorado Anti-Discrimination Act prohibiting discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation.

"At the core of this case is the right for everyone to speak consistent[ly] with what they believe, whether their views on marriage or other topics are similar to mine or perhaps different," Smith said. "Nobody should be punished for communicating and speaking and creating custom artwork that goes along the lines of what they believe."

Smith said she will work with anyone, including the LGBTQ community, but not for the specific purpose of gay weddings, adding that she makes creative decisions based on message and content, and that she serves all people, regardless of sexual orientation.

CHRISTIAN FLORIST SETTLING WITH SAME-SEX COUPLE AFTER NEARLY A DECADE FIGHTING ICONIC RELIGIOUS LIBERTY CASE

"I serve people from all different walks of life and I do have clients who identify as LGBT[Q]. I cannot create every message requested of me," she said. "There are some messages I can’t create no matter who requests them," she added.

Smith and her legal team have argued that her work constitutes speech and that Colorado's law compelling her to create messaging that is in conflict with her values is a violation of her First Amendment rights.

"The court has never compelled someone to create messages, meaning using their heart, their head and their hand to imagine and design art and use words and texts," Smith’s attorney, Kristen Waggoner of Alliance Defending Freedom, said in the Fox News interview.

"The court has never compelled that kind of speech even at the height of the civil rights era, it didn’t compel speech. Because that’s not the role of the government to tell Americans what is worthy of celebration….it’s disingenuous to suggest that this is about service. It’s about speech."

"It’s not the role of the government to mandate what is true and what is not. That’s the role of the citizen, to be able to decide what to express. No one should be forced to express a message that violates their convictions and in Colorado, they’re doing it upon threat of fines," Waggoner added, noting that "some jurisdictions impose jail time."

Some critics have argued that because Smith's content is unique, she’s creating a monopoly, and thereby restricting same-sex couples seeking a wedding website access to that monopoly. 

Waggoner rejected the argument, telling host Martha MacCallum that such a claim, if legitimized, "would turn the First Amendment on its head."

"That would mean every single one of us could be forced to express the government’s message," she said. "What is important here is that Colorado even agrees that Mrs. Smith serves all people. She does serve everyone. She has clients who identify as LGBT[Q] and she serves them. As the court many, many times today mentioned, her decisions turn on what the message is and not who the person is," Waggoner explained. 

"We all want that freedom," she continued. "Whether we’re a Democrat publicist and don’t want to write for a Republican or a pro-abortion photographer and don’t want to have to film or photograph a pro-life rally." 

The Munro SUV was born in the Scottish Highlands and is coming to the USA

You never know what you'll find on a trip into the wilderness, including ideas.

The Munro Mk_1 SUV is set to be the first vehicle produced in Scotland since the 1980s.

The full-size truck unveiled in Glasgow on Monday is an all-electric 4x4 that will be exported to the United States next year.

Company CEO Russell Peterson said it was inspired by an off-road excursion he took with company co-founder Ross Anderson in 2019.

REBOOTED SCOUT SUV TEASED AHEAD OF USA-BASED BRAND'S LAUNCH

"The off-roader we were driving through the Highlands was combustion-engined, and it was really struggling on the steep climbs. So, we were musing how much better it would be with an electric motor," he said.

"On the return journey, we stopped at a café in Braemar, where a bank of 50kW rapid chargers were sitting empty and unused. Parked up nearby was a large group of combustion-engined safari adventure 4x4s of a type that are no longer manufactured and will have to be replaced eventually. It dawned on us that there was a gap in the market for an electric-powered, four-wheel-drive, utilitarian workhorse. We envisioned a vehicle with ultimate, go-anywhere, off-road ability, unrestricted by road-derived underpinnings that limit the all-terrain ability of vehicles such as the 4x4 pickup trucks that have come to dominate the market."

CLICK HERE TO SIGN UP FOR OUR LIFESTYLE NEWSLETTER

The Mk_1 is being offered with the choice of either a 295 hp or 375 hp electric motor that drives the wheels through a traditional 4x4 system with some parts sourced from the classic Land Rover Defender, instead of powering the wheels directly like many EVs today.

The trucks have been developed primarily as commercial and adventure workhorses and are geared with a top speed of 80 mph, but the more powerful model can accelerate to 60 mph in less than five seconds.

TOYOTA LAUNCHING EXTREME TRAILHUNTER OFF-ROAD TRUCK LINEUP

The body is designed to offer extreme approach and departure angles and there is 11.5 inches of ground clearance below the axles. Its payload and towing capacities are rated at 2,200 pounds and 7,700 pounds respectively.

The Mk_1 will be available with battery packs of 61kWh and 82kWh capacities, the larger providing up to 190 miles of driving per charge, which Munro estimates is good for 16 hours of low speed off-road operation in its intended use cases. It is compatible with public DC fast-charging stations that can refill the battery to 80% in just over a half-hour. Pricing in the U.K. starts at the equivalent of $60,000, while a loaded Founders Edition model lists for $88,000.

Exports to the U.S. are scheduled to begin next year at a yet to be announced price. It will initially be sold under Class 3 truck with a sparsely appointed five-passenger interior, but a company spokesperson said that a light duty model is in development.

About Us

Virtus (virtue, valor, excellence, courage, character, and worth)

Vincit (conquers, triumphs, and wins)