Federal Judge Says School Hiding Kids’ Gender Transitions Doesn’t ‘Shock The Conscience,’ Throws Out Parent Lawsuit

A federal judge has thrown out a lawsuit from Massachusetts parents who accused public school officials of hiding their children’s gender transitions from them.

U.S. District Court Judge Mark Mastroianni, an Obama appointee, criticized Ludlow Public Schools officials for allegedly hiding the pair of siblings’ gender transitions from their parents, but he said the officials’ actions do not “shock the conscience.”

“While the court is apprehensive about the alleged policy and actions of the Ludlow Public Schools with regard to parental notification, it cannot conclude the decision to withhold information” about the children from their parents meets the conscience-shocking legal standard in Massachusetts, the judge wrote in his December 14 ruling.

Back in April, parents Stephen Foote and Marissa Silvestri filed a lawsuit in Massachusetts federal court against staff members at Paul R. Baird Middle School, as well as the elected school committee, and the town of Ludlow just east of Springfield, Massachusetts.

School officials “impermissibly inserted themselves into the private realm” of their family, violating their “rights to make decisions regarding their children’s upbringing, mental health, and well-being,” the parents wrote in their suit.

The parents claimed that school officials failed to inform them that their two children, an 11-year-old girl and a 12-year-old boy, were transitioning to a gender other than the one corresponding to their biological sex.

The 11-year-old girl allegedly emailed school staff in February 2021 and announced that she wanted to go by a cluster of new pronouns.

“I am genderqueer. … My new name will be R**** … If you deadname me or use any pronouns I am uncomfortable with I will politely tell you … A list of pronouns you can use are: she/her he/him they/them fae/faerae/aer ve/ver xe/xem ze/zir. … Please only use the ones I have listed and not the other ones. I do not like them,” the girl wrote, her parents said in court documents.

Afterward, a school counselor allegedly sent an email to staff ordering them not to tell her parents about the gender identity change.

“R**** [B****] is still in the process of telling his parents and is requesting that school staff refer to him as B**** and use she/her pronouns with her parents and in written emails/letters home,” the counselor wrote, according to the parents.

Meanwhile, the girl’s 12-year-old brother asked school staff to use female pronouns for him, and staff hid that information from his parents, the parents claimed.

The parents also said in court filings that they had previously even asked school staff not to have private conversations with their children about gender. However, they discovered that the superintendent, principal, guidance counselor, and teachers all ignored that request and were using the children’s new pronouns.

Later, the school even fired a teacher, Bonnie Manchester, 48, for telling the girl’s dad that she was transitioning to “genderqueer.”

In his ruling earlier this month throwing out the parents’ lawsuit, Mastroianni pointed to the requirement in Massachusetts for school officials not to discriminate against students on the basis of gender identity.

He also cited “the difficulties this issue presents and the competing interests involved.”

English Bishop Fires Back At Church Choir For Making Famous Christmas Carol ‘Woke’

A Catholic bishop slammed a church choir for altering a popular Christmas carol to include woke ideology and terminology in the song.

Cardinal Vincent Nichols, the Catholic Archbishop of Westminster, took issue with the song performed by All Saints with Holy Trinity choir in Loughborough, England.

“God rest you queer and questioning, your anxious hearts be still,” an altered line in “God Rest Ye Merry, Gentlemen,” said, according to Fox News.

“God rest you also, women, who by men have been erased,” another line in the song said. “Through history ignored and scorned, defiled and displaced.”

Nichols responded, “I think what Christmas does, and many other moments, it tells us the importance of ritual.”

“Ritual helps us to step outside of our own little bubble and connect with something we have received, inherited and that we hope to pass on,” he continued. “Those values are the continuation of musical repertoire, of the ability to sing together, of looking at the rituals that have been fashioned over centuries. Those are probably for me more important than particular sensitivities which come and go.”

Earlier this week, Catholic priest Father Frank Pavone fired back after being defrocked by the Vatican for allegedly political reasons, charging that his dismissal was due to cancel culture in the Catholic Church that needs “to be exposed.”

Pavone, who is the founder of Priests for Life, has become known for blasting President Biden and Democrats on social media, The Daily Wire reported. The Catholic News Agency (CNA) obtained a letter from Archbishop Christophe Pierre to U.S. bishops that claimed Pavone was dismissed for his social media activity and “persistent disobedience of the lawful instructions of his diocesan bishop.” In an email to the CNA, Pavone said that the news outlet had learned of the move before he had.

On Monday, Pavone spoke with Fox News host Laura Ingraham about the news.

“This is actually the culmination of 21 years of abuse by church authorities to me and to my ministry despite the fact that we help the Vatican,” he said. “We help to run some of the operations out of the pope’s mission to the United Nations. We help the secretary of state with international pro-life issues. We run the largest ministry for healing after abortion, for which Pope Francis has personally encouraged me to keep going on it. We do all kinds of other pro-life work, which many of our viewers are familiar.”

Pavone then attributed his apparent dismissal to cancel culture. A 2020 tweet from Pavone referred to “supporters of this goddamn loser Biden and his morally corrupt, America-hating, God-hating Democrat party.”

“Why are they doing this?” he asked. “A lot of it obviously is connected with the cancel culture that comes against supporters of President Trump and critics of the Democrat Party, and we’re only gonna get louder about that. We’re not going to be silenced.”

Pavone added that he would continue to be a leader in the pro-life movement.

“My vocation is to be a priest and to be a full-time pro-life leader and I don’t intend to walk away from either one of those,” he stated. Pavone also said he would appeal to the pope to reverse the decision.

“If the pope signs off on something, what they mean is there’s nobody in the church above the pope, we all understand this. But that doesn’t mean there’s no way to change this. The pope himself can reverse it, the next pope can reverse, and the people – I’m appealing to the people of God to continue working with us and show their support for this work of saving lives and healing hearts,” he said.

“It’s a cancel culture in the church. It’s got to be exposed and it’s got to be resisted,” Pavone concluded.

Hank Berrien contributed to this report.